Choosing the Best Exterior Shutter Color: Expert Tips

Published: August 13, 2021

By the Estate Millwork Design Team | Craftsmen since 1997

Black louvered shutters on a gray country house

When you are considering adding wood shutters to your home or replacing existing shutters, one of the most important decisions to be made is what color your finished shutters will be. Every color will create a different look and feel to the exterior of your home. Choosing your shutter color or accent color is probably the most important choice when it comes to making your home pop and stand out from the other homes around you.

What color is most popular?

When it comes to painting exterior shutters the most popular color is black. Black shutters are stately, universally appealing and fit with almost any home exterior. Having black shutters on your home will add definition, elegance and make your windows appear larger.

Other Color Options

Probably the second most popular shutter color behind black is white exterior shutters, with their timelessness and broad array of complementary colors; white shutters in particular will make windows appear larger.

Gray Shutters

Modern yet classic, gray wood shutters can be installed on a wide variety of homes. Gray exterior shutters have a distinct updated feel without being overly trendy; these shutters play nicely with loads of colors from lighter neutrals to the darker colors of brick and stone.

Blue Shutters

Blue exterior shutters are charming and serene, and much like blue jeans these shutters can pair with almost anything. Lighter blues look great along with dark grays and shades of white.

Earth Tone Shutters

Clean and earthy, natural wood or shades of olive and tan are very versatile. Similar to white shutters the lighter colors have the ability to make their respective windows appear larger without the stark contrast of white. Earth tone shutters pair well with other earth tones like deep greens, shades of brown and olive colors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best wood for exterior shutters?

Spanish Cedar, Cypress, and Western Red Cedar are top choices for exterior shutters due to their natural resistance to moisture, rot, and insects. Mahogany and Teak are premium alternatives offering exceptional durability and rich coloring. The best choice depends on your climate, budget, and desired aesthetic.

How long do custom wood shutters last?

With proper finishing and maintenance, custom wood shutters can last 20 years or more. Hardwood shutters built with mortise and tenon joinery are structurally superior to composite or vinyl alternatives, and they can be refinished multiple times to extend their lifespan even further.

Can wood shutters be used in humid climates?

Yes. Species like Spanish Cedar and Cypress have natural oils that resist moisture absorption and fungal growth. Proper sealing with a marine-grade exterior finish provides additional protection. Estate Millwork kiln-dries all lumber to optimal moisture content before milling to minimize warping.

What is the difference between louvered and raised panel shutters?

Louvered shutters feature angled slats that allow airflow and light control, making them ideal for ventilation. Raised panel shutters have a solid panel with a beveled center, offering a more traditional, formal appearance. Both styles are available in custom sizes and multiple wood species.

Expert Tips for Choosing and Maintaining Wood Shutters

Always measure the exact window opening before ordering. Custom shutters are built to your specifications, and accurate measurements ensure a perfect fit without costly adjustments.
Consider your home's architectural style when selecting a shutter design. Louvered shutters complement Colonial and Coastal homes, while raised panel shutters pair well with Federal and Georgian architecture.
Apply a high-quality exterior primer and paint or UV-resistant clear coat within two weeks of installation for unfinished shutters. This seals the wood against moisture and UV damage from day one.
Inspect your shutters annually for signs of finish wear, especially on south-facing and west-facing elevations that receive the most sun exposure. Touch up any bare spots promptly to prevent moisture intrusion.